More Hotels in Shelter Island Heights, NY
The Pridwin Hotel and Cottages
AAA Inspection Details
Overall Score: 4.1
Upscale style and amenities with the right touch of service.
Room
3.9
0
1
2
3
4
5
Spacious, Bedding Furniture, Seating, Television, Amenities, Technology, Style, Comfort
Bath
3.7
0
1
2
3
4
5
Layout, Vanity Area, Shower, Fixtures, Illumination, Amenities
Public Areas
4.9
0
1
2
3
4
5
Exterior, Facilities, Layout, Vibe, Food and Drink, Technology, Recreation
Top 25% of all hotels based on cleanliness and condition.
Staying here makes me feel as though I've traveled to a slower paced and gentler time, especially while rocking in a chair overlooking the calm bay.
AAA Inspector Notes
This iconic 1927 bay front resort got an incredible facelift in 2022, with a complete top-to-bottom coastal chic design. All deluxe accommodations feature plush robes and in-room Nespresso machines. All cottages have a gas fireplace and private patio. Seasonal beach service including lounge chairs, towels and umbrellas are complimentary. Theres also a dock to swim off of along with paddle boards and kayaks to borrow. In summer, guests are treated to a 30-minute boat ride around the harbor. Nighttime magic awaits, when multiple fireplaces are lit along with candles illuminating the interiors. This is when guests tend to congregate in the lounge where a live musician is often found playing acoustic guitar or relaxing along the covered porch watching the moon dance over Peconic Bay.
Smoke free premises. 49 units, some cottages. 1-4 stories, interior/exterior corridors. Bath: shower only. Accessibility (Call).
Amenities & Services
WiFi
Swimming Pool
Pet Friendly
Fitness Center
ECO Friendly
Electric Charging
Accessible
Business Center
Type
Classic Historic Resort Hotel
Location
Waterfront. 81 Shore Rd 11965.
Pool
heated outdoor.
Parking
on-site and valet.
Dining & Entertainment
restaurant, full bar, entertainment.
Room Amenities
refrigerators, coffeemakers, wireless Internet, safes.
Sports & Recreation
sauna, steamroom, beach on-site, motor boats, self-propelled boats, boat dock, fishing, tennis, bicycles, game room, lawn sports, exercise room, spa.
Guest Services
room service.
Terms
seasonal, pet friendly (call for restrictions/fees.).
Map
Get Directions